Join a Diaposi live session

Why people do not ask questions in lectures, and what changes it

What research says keeps a lecture hall silent, and what a lecturer can change this week, with or without a tool.

DiaposiUpdated 8 min read

In short

Students stay silent in lectures because asking in front of the room feels risky, not because they have nothing to ask. In a survey of 417 undergraduates, 47.7% said they never ask a question in large science courses, and those who never or rarely ask blamed anxiety first, then fear of being judged. To lower that risk: planned pauses, a word with a neighbour first, and written, anonymous questions.

  • Silence is not understanding: 47.7% of 417 surveyed undergraduates said they never ask a question in large science courses, yet over 90% said other people’s questions help them.
  • Those who never or rarely ask blame anxiety first (72.3%), then the fear of being judged (62.0%).
  • This week, with no tool: put question stops on slides, wait five seconds, let neighbours agree on one question, collect questions on paper.
  • Written, anonymous questions that the room can vote for address most of those causes at once. The studies cited here tested anonymous answers, not questions.
Contents
  1. Why don’t students ask questions in lectures?
  2. Who stays silent, and does the size of the room matter?
  3. Does silence mean everyone understood?
  4. What can you change this week, without any tool?
  5. Do written, anonymous questions bring more questions?
  6. Take anonymous questions on the slides you already have
  7. What it costs
  8. Questions and answers
  9. Your turn

Why don’t students ask questions in lectures?

Because asking in front of a full room costs more than it seems to give. The questions exist. What is missing is a safe way to ask them.

47.7%

In a survey of 417 undergraduates at one US research university, 47.7% said they never ask a question in their large science courses during a whole semester, although more than 90% said other people’s questions help them.

Source: Nadile EM et al. (2021) (external link)

The same survey asked the 361 students who never or rarely ask what holds them back. They could choose several reasons; the wording below is shortened.

What discourages askingShare who chose it
I feel anxious when I ask questions72.3%
I worry others will judge me62.0%
I can ask another student during class57.3%
I can look up the answer myself56.8%
I do not know the material well enough to ask a good question53.1%
I can ask the instructor outside class50.7%
It would take away from other students’ class time32.4%
Another student will likely ask my question23.6%
I would not get a detailed enough answer in the time there is21.7%

Source: Nadile et al., PLOS ONE, 2021 (external link), table 3. Two families of reasons stand out. The first is fear: anxiety, being judged, a question that does not feel good enough. The second is a way round: a neighbour, a search, or a word with you outside the lecture, where the answer reaches one person instead of the room.

These figures come from one university, from science courses, and from what students say about themselves: a pattern to check in your own room, not a law.

Who stays silent, and does the size of the room matter?

Silence is not spread evenly. Observers who sat in 34 university life sciences classes found that, in an average session, 32% of the men and 22% of the women present spoke at least once (Bailey et al., 2020 (external link)). That is one university, and it counts every spoken contribution, not only questions. Either way, most of the room said nothing.

The survey points the same way: women were 2.4 times more likely than men to report never asking a question (Nadile et al., 2021 (external link)).

Size widens the gap. Across more than 5,300 observed exchanges between students and instructors in STEM courses, class size was the factor that most reduced women’s participation (Ballen et al., BioScience, 2019 (external link)).

Group work does not fix this by itself. Even in a course built on active learning, men spoke more than their share of the room, above all when answers were volunteered aloud after group discussion (Aguillon et al., 2020 (external link)). While the only channel is a voice in front of everyone, the same people tend to use it.

Does silence mean everyone understood?

No. Silence tells you that asking felt too costly, not that the slide was clear. Of the 376 students in the survey who said other people’s questions help them, 96.0% said they sometimes have the same question, and 77.7% that they sometimes feel uncomfortable asking themselves (Nadile et al., 2021 (external link), table 2). A question kept back is a loss for the room, not for one person.

It costs you too. A question is the cheapest signal you get about where an explanation failed, and when only a few confident voices ask, the lecture gets tuned to them.

What can you change this week, without any tool?

Each move below lowers the cost of asking, and none needs a screen.

  1. Put the question stop on a slide

    Plan two or three stops inside the lecture, each on a slide of its own. A stop at the very end competes with people packing their bags.

  2. Count to five

    A review of classroom research on wait time found that, after asking a question, the person teaching typically waits less than one second for a reply (Rowe, 1986 (external link)). Count silently to five before you speak again. It will feel long.

  3. Let neighbours talk first

    Give the room one minute to agree on one question with a neighbour. In the survey, 57.3% of those who never or rarely ask said they can ask another student instead. Use that habit: a question shared by two is easier to say aloud.

  4. Collect questions on paper

    Hand out slips or index cards and collect them unsigned, at a stop or at the door. Nobody is seen asking, and nobody has to speak. Open the next lecture with the questions that came up most.

  5. Invite, do not pick

    Calling on someone who has not volunteered does not make speaking safer. In interviews with 52 students in large science courses, cold call and random call were said to raise anxiety, never to lower it (Cooper, Downing and Brownell, 2018 (external link)). Ask which pair will share its question, then wait. Keep the paper slips for those who will not.

  6. Answer the first question well

    Repeat it so the whole room hears it, thank the person, answer briefly. The first exchange shows everyone else what asking will cost them.

Six things to say instead of “Any questions?”

  1. What was the least clear point so far? Write it down, then compare with your neighbour.
  2. Which step could you not redo alone tonight?
  3. What question do you think someone near you has?
  4. If this came up in the exam, which part would you want explained again?
  5. What should I say a second time, more slowly?
  6. I will take three questions before the next part. I will wait.

Do written, anonymous questions bring more questions?

Probably, though no study cited here tested it in a lecture hall. The research on anonymity is about answering, and it points one way. When 128 students answered opinion questions anonymously on a keypad instead of raising a hand, their answers followed the group less, and the shyest students said they preferred the keypad (Stowell, Oldham and Bennett, 2010 (external link)).

In lectures at three universities, participation differed significantly between keypads and raised hands, and students said the keypad’s anonymity made them take part more (Barr, 2017 (external link)). Both studies used hardware keypads. What carries over to a phone is the mechanism: nobody sees who answered.

A written channel changes the picture too. In live online classes during the pandemic, only 14% of surveyed students at one US university and 10% at an Australian one said they asked questions by raising a hand, while 55% used the chat (Salehi et al., PLOS ONE, 2023 (external link)). Those were online classes, not lecture halls, so take the direction, not the numbers.

Put together, four properties look worth having: the question is written, anonymous, open to votes, and sent at any moment. The table sets each cause against a way to lower it.

What holds people backWithout a toolWith written, anonymous questions on phones
Anxiety, fear of being judgedUnsigned paper slipsThe question arrives without a name
“My question is not good enough”A minute with a neighbour firstVotes show that others share it
“It would take class time”Question stops planned on slidesSent at any moment, answered at the stop
“Someone else will ask”One written question per pairOne tap to vote for a question already asked
“I will ask after the lecture”Answer after-class questions for everyone at the start of the next lectureAsked during the lecture, answered for the whole room

Two limits. Paper is slow in a large hall, and nobody sees that a neighbour had the same question. And an anonymous channel needs a rule: you read it at the stops, and you take out what does not belong.

Take anonymous questions on the slides you already have

Anxiety and the fear of being judged were the reasons chosen most in the survey, and both come from being seen. In Diaposi, you present the PowerPoint, PDF or Word file you already have from the browser, the room joins on phones, and questions arrive in writing, anonymous by default, with votes. There is no add-in for you and no app for them.

  1. Upload the deck you already have

    Sign up, then drop your PowerPoint, PDF or Word file (10 MB at most) on Host a session and answer two setup questions. The deck is presented from the browser as it is.

    The Host band of the dashboard and its upload card: Drop your presentation here, PowerPoint, Word or PDF, Max 10 MB, Upload a file.
  2. Show the code and let the room write

    Participants scan the QR code or type the 8-digit code at diaposi.com, with no account, and give a name once. They see your slides on their phone and type a question about the slide in front of them. It arrives without a name unless its author ticks Show my name, a choice that then holds for the session.

    A participant’s question box shown twice: a question about slide 20 with Show my name unticked, then the same question with Show my name ticked and, under it, the line: Once you post with your name, it stays on everything you post in this session.
  3. Let the room vote

    The room votes questions up or down, and the same question asked twice is counted once, with its number. It answers “someone else will ask” and “my question is not good enough”: one tap shows that a question is shared.

    Three questions sent anonymously, each with its up and down votes; the first is marked Asked 3 times and has just received one more vote.
  4. Answer the top questions at your stop

    Open the Q&A panel beside the slide with one key; the room’s screens keep the slide. Sort by Top, pin a question for later, mark one answered, take an off-topic or offensive one off the screen. Every question stays in the session report with its slide, its time and its votes.

    The host’s Q&A panel on the Top tab, with the tabs All, Top, Pinned and Done and three controls: Pin for later, Mark answered, Take off the screen.
Take anonymous questions on your slides for free

What it costs

  • Hosting is free during the beta, with no card: your slides with live questions, polls and quizzes, and a report after every session.
  • Participants never pay. They join with a code, with no account and no app.
  • The paid host plans are not for sale yet: you can join the waitlist, and a school or a company can contact us.
See the plans for hosts

On the site

  • Anonymous Q&A

    How questions, votes and the host’s panel work, screen by screen.

  • Live interactive presentation

    Everything a session adds to your slides: Q&A, polls, quizzes and the report.

  • For education

    Diaposi for higher education: an interactive lecture from the document you already use.

Questions and answers

Does asking “Any questions?” at the end of a lecture work?

Not well. It comes when people are packing up, it asks them to speak in front of everyone, and it seldom gets enough silence: in classroom research, the person teaching typically waits less than one second for a reply after asking a question (Rowe, 1986). Move the question stops inside the lecture, word them precisely, and wait five seconds.

Why are students afraid to answer questions in class?

Mostly because they fear being wrong in public. In a survey of 417 undergraduates, three out of four of those who never or rarely answer (75.6%) said they are not confident that their answer is correct (Nadile et al., PLOS ONE, 2021). The same fear holds back questions, so offer a first try in writing, without a name.

What if the room stays silent even with anonymous questions?

Make the first question a task, not an invitation. At the first stop, ask everyone to write the least clear point so far, then to vote for one question they share, and answer the top one at once. The aim is for people to see a question like theirs answered with nobody named.

Can participants stay anonymous in Diaposi, and what does the host see?

Yes. A question is anonymous by default and shows a name only if its author chooses Show my name; from then on, that name stays on what they post in the session. Reactions never carry a name. The host’s report lists participants by the name they gave when they joined, and keeps every question. Reports are kept 12 months after the session, then deleted.

What is Diaposi?

Diaposi is a French EdTech ecosystem for interactive presentations and augmented learning: hosts run live polls, quizzes and anonymous questions on the PowerPoint, PDF or Word file they already have, and learners study their own documents with AI explanations, quizzes and mock exams.

Sources

9
  1. Nadile EM, Alfonso E, Barreiros BM, Bevan-Thomas WD, Brownell SE, et al. (2021). Call on me: undergraduates’ perceptions of voluntarily asking and answering questions in front of large-enrollment science classes. PLOS ONE 16(1):e0243731. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0243731 (external link)
  2. Bailey EG, Greenall RF, Baek DM, et al. (2020). Female in-class participation and performance increase with more female peers and/or a female instructor in life sciences courses. CBE Life Sciences Education 19(3):ar30. doi.org/10.1187/cbe.19-12-0266 (external link)
  3. Ballen CJ, Aguillon SM, Awwad A, et al. (2019). Smaller classes promote equitable student participation in STEM. BioScience 69(8):669-680. doi.org/10.1093/biosci/biz069 (external link)
  4. Aguillon SM, Siegmund GF, Petipas RH, Drake AG, Cotner S, Ballen CJ (2020). Gender differences in student participation in an active-learning classroom. CBE Life Sciences Education 19(2):ar12. doi.org/10.1187/cbe.19-03-0048 (external link)
  5. Rowe MB (1986). Wait time: slowing down may be a way of speeding up. Journal of Teacher Education 37(1):43-50. doi.org/10.1177/002248718603700110 (external link)
  6. Cooper KM, Downing VR, Brownell SE (2018). The influence of active learning practices on student anxiety in large-enrollment college science classrooms. International Journal of STEM Education 5:23. doi.org/10.1186/s40594-018-0123-6 (external link)
  7. Stowell JR, Oldham T, Bennett D (2010). Using student response systems (“clickers”) to combat conformity and shyness. Teaching of Psychology 37(2):135-140. doi.org/10.1080/00986281003626631 (external link)
  8. Barr ML (2017). Encouraging college student active engagement in learning: student response methods and anonymity. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 33(6):621-632. doi.org/10.1111/jcal.12205 (external link)
  9. Salehi S, Ballen CJ, Bolander Laksov K, Ismayilova K, Poronnik P, Ross PM, Tzioumis V, Wieman C (2023). Global perspectives of the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on learning science in higher education. PLOS ONE 18(12):e0294821. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0294821 (external link)

Your turnone tap, no account

When you ask “Any questions?” in a lecture, what usually happens?

One tap. The result appears after your answer.

Was this guide useful?

One tap. Add a sentence if you like.

Private: nothing you write is shown to other readers.

Ask a question, anonymously

No name, no account. Only Diaposi reads it.

Sign in to get the answer by e-mail.

Bring someone in

Preparing this with someone? Send them the guide, or show it to the whole room.

The QR code opens this guide on any phone.

Join Diaposi news

New guides and what is new in Diaposi. One letter every two weeks, no spam.

Unsubscribe anytime. See the Privacy Policy.